validating-and-publishing-canvases

A canvas's source lives in PostHog, versioned per publish. Publishing is guarded: every edit is based on a specific version, and the server refuses to overwrite newer work. Every publish queues a server-side build, and the canvas renders the last successful build.

canvas-source-retrieve returns:

• project — schemaVersion (1), files (path → content), entryHtml ("index.html"), dependencies (exact platform-pinned versions), canvasSdkVersion, capabilities.
• current_version_id — the version your edits are based on. Keep it; the publish needs it. It is null for a canvas that has never been published — pass that null on the first publish.

Keep index.html and dependencies exactly as returned. You may add relative source files and admitted assets to the project. Use ?worker for a self-contained module worker and represent binary assets as base64 entries in assets; new npm dependencies or dependency-version drift fail validation.

The host enforces project.capabilities at runtime, so an undeclared ph call builds fine and then dies in the rendered canvas. Declare:

• capabilities.posthog.insights — every insight short id the canvas passes to ph.loadInsight.
• capabilities.posthog.captureEvents — every event name it passes to ph.capture.
• capabilities.posthog.inlineQueries: true — when it calls ph.query at all.
• capabilities.posthog.agentRequests: true — when it calls ph.agent.request.
• capabilities.connectors — one { "provider", "tools" } entry per third-party provider the canvas reads through ph.connectors.call, listing every tool it calls on that provider. A provider is a native id (github) or mcp:<server host> (mcp:mcp.calendly.com). Unknown providers, unregistered native tools, and private MCP hosts fail validation; every declared tool must have is_read_only: true in the catalog. An upstream hint alone does not grant access. A canvas with connectors cannot declare shared state.
• capabilities.network.origins — each exact HTTPS origin used by fetch, XMLHttpRequest, or an external stylesheet, image, font, media file, or frame. Remote scripts remain blocked. Do not include paths, credentials, queries, fragments, or wildcards. The host must be public: loopback and private IPs, single-label names like intranet, and the .local, .localhost, .internal, and .home.arpa suffixes are all rejected, so a local dev host such as https://localhost:8010 fails validation with an invalid_network_origin error. Data sent to a declared origin leaves PostHog and appears in the capability review before promotion.

Before validation, inventory every literal external URL in every source file. Classify navigation links and ph.openExternal() URLs as navigation; they do not need a network origin. For every request or resource URL, declare its scheme + host + optional port only. Include every origin a request redirects to and every secondary origin a stylesheet references for fonts or images. Never infer that one CDN hostname covers another.

Validation rejects undeclared literal calls and resource URLs (capability_missing_* diagnostics) so you can fix them before publishing. Dynamic URLs and redirect destinations cannot be inferred, so the inventory is still required even when validation is clean.

canvas-validate-create is side-effect free; call it as often as needed. Diagnostics carry severity, a stable code, a message, and (for file-specific problems) path and line:

• error diagnostics block publishing — fix all of them. Common ones: import_not_allowed (bare imports are limited to the dependencies returned in the source project), forbidden_dynamic_import / forbidden_require / forbidden_inline_script, invalid_path, capability_missing_insight / capability_missing_capture_event / capability_missing_inline_queries / capability_missing_agent_requests / capability_missing_network_origin, dependency_not_admitted / dependency_version_mismatch, platform_token_redeclared (a CSS variable named like a Quill token that the platform stylesheet sets on every element, so the value never applies; prefix your own variables), and path/size violations.
• warning diagnostics don't block, but heed them: network_fetch / network_xhr mean the code reaches for the network directly. Declare the exact HTTPS origin or use the ph bridge.

Publishing goes live immediately and is the default way to save a change, for a canvas's first version and for every follow-up edit. Every version records who published it and which task did the work, so the history stays reviewable after the fact. Stage a draft instead only when the user asked for a draft, a preview, or a review step — see "Draft, then promote" below.

Two ways to publish, both guarded:

• Edits — canvas-edit-create with operations. This is the default for any change to a canvas that already has source. The guard is mandatory here because an edit's meaning depends on its base.
• Whole project — canvas-publish-create with the complete project, for a first version or to replace everything.

For an edit with canvas-edit-create:

• Use str_replace for a change inside a file: old_string is text copied from the file you read, with a few surrounding lines so it matches exactly one place. Set replace_all: true to change every match, for example a rename.
• Use write with the complete content for a new file or a full rewrite, delete to remove a file, and rename with new_path to move one.
• When the change needs a new capability, for example a ph.state scope, also send capabilities with the complete new capabilities (the current ones plus the addition) in the same edit. Do not switch to canvas-publish-create for that.
• Put every operation of one change into one call. They apply in order, and the whole edit is rejected if any operation fails.
• A 400 lists each failed operation by index. edit_no_match shows the closest lines of the file and edit_ambiguous_match lists the lines that match. Fix those operations from the diagnostic and send the edit again. If one replacement fails twice, write that whole file instead.
• The response returns the new current_version_id. Pass it to the next edit. When you published or edited the canvas earlier in this session, do not call canvas-source-retrieve before the next edit: you already know the source, and a 409 version_conflict tells you when the canvas changed.

For a whole-project publish with canvas-publish-create:

• Always pass expected_current_version_id — the current_version_id you read (or explicit null on a first publish). Unguarded publishes can silently clobber concurrent edits.
• Include a short prompt describing the change; it becomes the version-history entry's label.
• Pass name only to rename the canvas (e.g. a first build of an untitled canvas).
• Publish once per requested change. If the user asks for another edit afterwards, re-read the source (the head may have moved) and publish again — don't batch unrelated changes into one version, and don't publish work-in-progress after every micro-edit.
• A 429 means the team's build capacity is temporarily exhausted. Wait ~30 seconds and retry the same publish; nothing was saved.

The response returns the new current_version_id.

A publish queues a server-side build of the version. The canvas does not update until the build is ready, and nobody else is watching the result — you own it. The publish or edit response already carries build.build_status. When it is ready or failed, act on it without another call. Only while it is queued or building, poll canvas-builds-retrieve every few seconds (up to ~2 minutes) until the build you queued is terminal:

• queued/building — in progress; poll again shortly.
• ready — the canvas's published_build_id advances to this build (unless a newer publish superseded it first). The task's canvas work is done.
• failed — read the build's error diagnostics, fix the project, and publish again. A failed build never replaces the last good one, so the canvas keeps rendering the previous version — finishing the task here would leave the user with a stale canvas and a silent failure.

Runtime error reports (filed on the authoring task when a rendered canvas throws) name the build they came from. A report from an older build id is history, not evidence about your current code — check it against the build you just published before acting on it. In particular, a report that a documented ph API is undefined (e.g. ph.state) means that artifact was baked by an older host runtime: republish so a current build replaces it. Never "fix" it by removing the API or its capability declaration.

Publishing goes live the moment its build is ready, and that is the default. Use a draft only when the user asked for one: a preview to look at first, a review step before going live, or an explicit "don't publish yet". A draft is a real, buildable version that is never the head: the live canvas keeps rendering the current version until someone promotes the draft. This is different from canvas-validate-create, which only compile-checks and produces no build or preview.

1. Stage — canvas-draft-create with the complete project (same shape, capabilities, and validation as a publish). No expected_current_version_id: a draft is based on nothing and conflicts with nothing. The response returns the draft's version_id, its queued build, and capability_widening — the insights, capture events, inline queries, and network origins the draft declares beyond the live version. Surface a non-empty widening to the user before promoting; it is the access the change would newly grant.
2. Wait for the build — poll canvas-builds-retrieve until the draft's build is terminal, the same way you would after a publish. A failed draft build is fixed by staging a new draft, not by promoting.
3. Preview — read the draft's files with canvas-source-retrieve passing its version_id; once its build is ready the app renders that draft when the version is opened. The draft is not in canvas-versions-retrieve (that lists published history only) and cannot be reverted onto — list pending drafts with canvas-drafts-retrieve.
4. Promote — when the user approved the draft or asked to go live; a draft the user asked to review stays staged until they say so. canvas-promote-create makes the draft the live head. Pass expected_current_version_id (the live current_version_id from canvas-source-retrieve); it is guarded exactly like a publish and 409s on a moved head (recover as below). A draft whose build is still ready goes live with no rebuild; otherwise a fresh build is queued, so wait for it as in step 2. Promote is the only path from a draft to live.

A 409 means the canvas moved past your base — a concurrent publish or a revert. The response includes the live current_version_id. Never retry unguarded to force your version through:

1. Re-read the source with canvas-source-retrieve.
2. Re-apply your edits to the fresh source (the new head may contain the user's own edits — preserve them, and do not report them in your reply).
3. Publish again with the new current_version_id.

Each publish appends a full source version and moves the head pointer; users can revert to older versions in the app (which republishes and rebuilds them). The guard matters because basing your publish on the version you actually read is what keeps a user's revert, another agent's publish, and your edit from silently erasing each other.